Reviews about Maybelline TattooStudio Smokey Gel Pencil Eyeliner

The quality of the pencil is superb, I have had several brown ones before. But this time I decided to go for "Smokey grey" and it was a complete disappointment in terms of color! It is almost invisible on the eyes!

I bought the Smokey grey pencil. The pencil itself is good, soft, and the color on the hand is really taupe (as the girls wrote in the reviews, that's why I chose it) and it stays well. However... on the eyelids, the color is not visible at all, it blends with the skin. I will try it for my eyebrows. So far, it seems like a waste of money. I should have gotten the black one.

I really liked the pencil, especially the fact that it doesn't need sharpening. It is easy to apply and it also easily washes off. It doesn't smudge and stays in place well, although I should have chosen a slightly darker shade, something like dark brown instead of smoky.

I didn't like the eyeliner. It smudges in the corners after just a few hours. It's probably not suitable for girls with hooded eyelids.

The pencil applies smoothly, without smudging, and is quite long-lasting.

I have been buying this product for a while now. I am satisfied with its quality. It lasts the whole day without leaking.

The pencil is soft and does not wash off with water - perfect for washing your face or as a long-lasting makeup tool. It's exactly what I was looking for.

I will give it 4 stars as my eyes start to ache a little after using it. After only 3-4 hours, my eyes begin to feel tired. However, the color is nice and the texture is soft.

The color is stunning, I chose the gray shade, which is actually closer to taupe. It might even be suitable for filling in someone's eyebrows. You just need to apply it and wait for it to dry, then it sets. I give it a preliminary rating of 5. At the bottom is the Maybelline eyeshadow in taupe, In the middle is the smokey grey gel pencil, And at the top is the Vipera mineral 04.

On the other side of the pencil, hidden under the sponge for blending, there is a sharpener. The packaging is pleasant and of good quality. The plastic is sturdy, scratch-resistant, and the writings on it do not disappear over time. That's all for the positives. My pencil is in the color Smokey Black. It blends poorly, making a smooth transition from a bright color to a semi-transparent smoky effect is not possible. As an eyeliner, it doesn't stay in place the way I applied it, even though I don't have oily skin. Throughout the day, it annoyingly disappears from my eyes in tiny pieces, almost like dots. However, removing it completely with micellar water (I use Bioderma Hydrabio H2O) is very difficult for delicate skin. It's a complete disappointment, unfortunately.