Reviews about Make-Up Atelier Paris Eyeliner

The eyeliner is terrible! I bought it in black. According to the description, it should be a matte black, but in reality, it's glossy and excessively shiny. It looks like a film on the eyelid, very cheap. After just one hour of application, it starts to crack and form bald spots. There is no information about the ingredients or expiration date on the eyeliner, and the plastic itself is very fragile. The eyeliner arrived without any packaging. After a month of purchase, it became very thick. It's definitely not worth the money. I strongly do not recommend it!

I am very satisfied with this eyeliner! I chose the black color. The product stays on perfectly for a long time and doesn't smudge.