Catherine Arley Deep Black Dipliner Matte Eyeliner

I really didn't like it. The brush is stiff and pinches the eyelid. Moreover, it is difficult to apply evenly with it, as if you were using some kind of stick to paint. The color is not vibrant, rather a very dark gray. And it also smudges and leaves imprints on the eyelid.

I didn't like the eyeliner. The brush is terribly uncomfortable, it scratches the eyelid and doesn't apply the product well. It also flakes off throughout the day.

I used to use Cherel Perfect Contour Liner eyeliner, made in Italy. For me, it was the best eyeliner (the brush was thinner and longer). At first, I had trouble getting used to the brush because it was thick and stiff. But after a short period of time, I got used to it and now I am completely satisfied with the result (which is on my face: it looks decent and washes off quite well).

The eyeliner is not very good: it looks dull (not vibrant) on the eyes, smudges and flakes off throughout the day, and is impossible to completely remove during makeup removal, so you have to wash your face again and again. I will go back to my favorite Vivienne Sabo eyeliner.

Good eyeliner, pigmented, just a bit prone to fallout.

This eyeliner is really awesome! The brush is superb, and the color and lasting power are great. I highly recommend it.

This matte eyeliner is really cool, it stays on well with a brush. It doesn't smudge in any weather conditions.