Maybelline The Colossal Kajal 12H Long-Lasting Eye Pencil

Not durable at all.

Unfortunately, it didn't work for me. I bought it to apply eyeliner between my lashes, but the pencil isn't suitable for that purpose.

The product lacks stability and tends to spread.

The product doesn't last long, smudges on the eyelids, and leaves marks under the eyes. It's also difficult to remove with regular micellar water; you need something stronger to avoid the "panda effect." Overall, it's disappointing.

It turned out to be not durable. I'm disappointed.

I would love to give it 5 stars, but unfortunately, I can't. It draws well with a soft, coal-black color. However, it doesn't last at all. After half an hour, it smudges onto the skin, leaving dark circles under the eyes. Unfortunately, I can't recommend it.

The black color is nice, but it leaves marks under the eyes, which looks terrible. It's disappointing that such a reputable brand is letting me down.

I really liked the pencil! It stays on all day without smudging into the crease above the eye and is easily removed with micellar water. I applied it on bare skin, over primer, and on top of eyeshadow—it holds up perfectly. Thanks to my favorite Makeup store for the fast delivery.

The pencil is great—soft, applies easily, and doesn't smudge.

I really liked this pencil. It is soft, quite durable, applies easily, and doesn't break.

I love this kohl pencil. I've been using it for years to create winged eyeliner. The lines stay sharp and don't smudge throughout the day! In my opinion, it's the best eyeliner pencil out there!

I didn't buy it here, but the eyeliner pencil is terrible. It works on my hand but not on my eyelid. It was a waste of money, and it wasn't cheap. Even one star is too much.

I liked it! It stays well on the skin. It doesn't smudge but can be easily removed with micellar water.

The product is not long-lasting at all; it smudges throughout the day and lasts for a maximum of 15 minutes.

I've purchased this eyeliner pencil for the second time and overall, I'm happy with how it applies. The only downside is that it smudges a little on the eyelid throughout the day, but it's not a major issue.

The product lacks staying power; within half an hour of applying the pencil, I ended up with panda eyes. I've never had such an unstable eyeliner before. However, it's worth mentioning that it is indeed waterproof, though this doesn't really help because it's almost impossible to remove the panda eyes afterward!

The durability is excellent, and it's a good product.

One of my favorite pencils. I recommend it.

The pencil is soft and very easy to draw with, and it washes off effortlessly. However, it has no staying power at all. Within just a few minutes, it transfers onto the lower eyelid. Neither an eyeshadow primer nor an eyeliner base helps prevent this. I usually like many Maybelline products, but this one was a complete disappointment.

I order this product regularly; it's my favorite. I use it for my lower lash line. It doesn't smudge and can be easily removed with micellar water.

Horrible. I don't understand where the positive reviews are coming from. It's not suitable for the lower eyelid. It smudges immediately, even after trying to set it with eyeshadow before applying. No results. However, when it does smudge under the eyes, it can only be removed with micellar water meant for waterproof makeup.

The color is nice, but it isn't long-lasting.

I really liked it! I will order again.

Ordinary pencil. Durable.

The pencil is fantastic; it applies smoothly and lasts quite a long time.

I really like it!

Great eyeliner pencil! It doesn't smudge, is long-lasting, and is soft yet easy to use for drawing precise lines.

The pencil is very soft, provides a clear outline, and is extremely easy to use. It's fantastic!

The best eyeliner ever! It applies smoothly and stays on perfectly. I've been using it for over 2 years, and nothing else compares. It's an absolute gem, with a rich black color that's just amazing! I definitely recommend it!

Maybelline has never let me down. This eyeliner pencil is amazing—rich black and long-lasting. I've been using it for a long time. Highly recommend it.

1. Yes, this is a kohl pencil, which means, as mentioned earlier, it's designed for the waterline and as a base for smoky eyes (so that your stunning look doesn’t appear patchy in photos).
2. It may smudge if used on the lash line, like eyeliner—it’s bound to smudge because it's not meant for that. However, it can be used as a base for creating a soft eyeliner effect with eyeshadow.

This is a decent kohl pencil. It's BLACK and applies easily to the waterline. I find it a bit too soft for drawing precise lines, so it's not ideal for creating winged eyeliner. It does smudge a little, so I touch it up throughout the day with a cotton swab. Despite this, it's still my top choice since I use it specifically as kohl and not for eyeliner. Plus, the price is reasonable.

Apologies for the harsh tone, but here’s my take: The pencil is great, so what's the issue? If you're struggling to use it, that's on you. Criticizing the product due to your lack of experience with kohl and waterlines is quite unreasonable. The kohl is good, and it's not difficult to adjust and learn how to use it properly. Best of luck! As always, delivery was fast.

No other pencil has smudged as much as this one did for me. I applied it along the upper lash line, but it ended up smeared both above and below my eyes. I don't have oily eyelids and have never had issues with pencils before. This is the first time I've experienced something like this.

Amazing eyeliner pencil! I use it on my upper eyelid to draw between the lashes or create a winged look. I set it with black eyeshadow using a thin brush. It stays put from morning until night and doesn’t smudge, probably because I always apply eyeshadow on top. It removes easily with any eye makeup remover—I use Garnier's micellar water.

This product is terrible! It doesn't stay on the waterline at all, and it's supposed to be a kajal that should hold there. I definitely don't recommend it. It smudges under the eyes and creates a mess!

The product smudges terribly. :/

I read the reviews and realized they were quite mixed, so I decided to try it myself. The pencil is jet black and very long-lasting. I was able to draw eyeliner with it easily, and it applied well. Throughout the day, it didn’t smudge or fade. Toward the end of the day, I did rub my eye a bit, and it smeared slightly, but I was able to wipe it off carefully. It didn’t transfer onto the upper eyelid, and I removed it with a two-phase makeup remover. Overall, I’m very satisfied. The pencil is excellent and met all my expectations. Thank you for the delivery and the gift!

The pencil is waterproof and doesn't come off with regular micellar water. I used it for holiday makeup and tried to make some adjustments, but it was difficult to remove even with almond oil. I hadn't realized it was long-lasting and doesn't wash off with soap at all. I ended up having to remove all my makeup and start over.

Here’s a coherent translation of the review:

"This is the worst eyeliner I've ever used. It doesn't stay on at all. Actually, it does stay on, but only when it smudges under the eyes, and then it's impossible to remove for two days with anything. It's really disappointing because every other eye makeup product from Maybelline has worked well for me."

You need to get used to the kayak, but I have no complaints about the product itself. However, it was delivered without any packaging, so who knows, it might have been unpacked six months or even a year ago, which reduces its shelf life (24 months from the time of opening). Even if it hasn't been used, it's unpleasant.

Here's a coherent translation of the product review: "Anyone who says this pencil is bad just doesn't know how to use makeup! The pencil is fantastic!"

This pencil is very soft. It gets used up quickly and applies in a thick layer.

This is the worst eyeliner I've ever used! It gives you the raccoon eye effect, even if you have the driest skin. It wouldn't even work for a Halloween zombie look because this extra black color smudges everywhere! Absolutely terrible!

The product truly lives up to its name as a "kajal": it's soft and black. For those who want it to be long-lasting, remember to apply eyeshadow on top.

After hearing so many beauty bloggers rave about it, I decided to buy it. What a mistake! The application is terrible—it smudges everywhere: on the waterline, the lower eyelid, the upper eyelid. I ended up looking like a panda. Don't make the same mistake I did; avoid buying this pencil.

The eyeliner isn't for me. I find it really difficult to remove from my eyes. It dries instantly, so it's impossible to make any corrections if needed.

I really liked the pencil. It's creamy, but once it sets, it stays on well.

For the price, this is an excellent pencil.

I really liked the pencil. It’s long-lasting and creates a precise line. Thanks for the delivery, Make Up! As always, everything is excellent!