Seventeen Supersmooth Waterproof Eyeliner Waterproof Eyeliner

Not long-lasting. Smudges. Maybelline is better for the same price.

I constantly buy these pencils. Shades 05 and 13 are my favorites. They stay on well throughout the day, they don't melt or smudge in the heat. Shade 10 is also good, it works great for accentuating the eyes.

I did not see any lasting power with this product. Overall, it applies well and the area between the lashes appears lighter. In the photo, I have applied it to the area between my lashes. This is the number 10 pencil.

This is an excellent silicone-based pencil! I have been searching for this shade for a long time, and finally found it. It is easy to draw with and it stays on well. I haven't tried applying it on the mucous membrane. It is pencil number 11 and can be applied in 1 or 3 layers. The pencil comes in plastic and sharpens without any issues.

The pencil is genuinely waterproof, does not smudge, and lasts the entire day. I highly recommend it.

The product dried up within a month and started to crumble into tiny pieces.

This is my favorite pencil, number 15, in blue. To say that it suits me very well is an understatement. I have 5 of these pencils in stock. The quality is great, it lasts on my eyes until the evening.

This is a great pencil, it's soft and really doesn't smudge. I bought the brown one. I highly recommend it.

Great pencil, it draws well and doesn't smudge.

The pencil is amazing. I have been ordering it for several years now.

It works great on the surface! If it doesn't work for you, try wiping the surface with a tissue. It is excellent at drawing! This pencil is amazing!

This is an excellent pencil that lasts all day without smudging. I have been using it for about five years now.

These are absolutely useless. I bought the olive and beige ones, but they don't draw on the skin and leave clumps on the lashes.

I got the black one for smudging on the eyelids. It won't work well for thin eyeliner. The pencil is soft and excellent. Smudging should be done quickly.

I tried the matte beige shade for my eyelids. Unfortunately, it is completely unsuitable for this purpose as it doesn't apply smoothly and the pencil clumps up on my lashes. The staying power is decent, it doesn't smudge, but it can be easily removed with regular micellar water within a minute.

The pencil is fantastic. It doesn't smudge and it lasts a long time. It's worth every penny, I would rate it 11 out of 10. I deducted one star only because it leaves imprints on the mucous membrane, but other than that, I will definitely buy it again!

This pencil is great for drawing precise lines, but it's impossible to create thin strokes.

The pencil is amazing! If it dries out, it stays firmly on the mucous membrane. It can be smudged, but you need to work quickly. For sharpening, it's better to keep it in the freezer for a little bit.

For those who have trouble with it staying on, here's a life hack. You need to apply it on a DRY surface. So, wipe the mucous membrane with a regular tissue, it will remove excess moisture and the pencil will adhere perfectly.

Shades on the swatch:
50 - beige with a hint of pink, great for highlighting the corner, matte finish.
05 - brown, coffee with tiny sparkles.
15 - deep blue, slightly satin finish.
52 - plum, very beautiful, matte.
13 - olive, satin finish.
17 - turquoise, satin finish.

I was really looking forward to receiving my order, but I ended up getting a pencil in the wrong color. I'm not sure if it was my mistake, as I wanted a black one, but I ordered 10 and received 10 pencils in a gray shade. I bought them for my slime activities, but they don't work well for drawing on it. I'm quite disappointed.

The pencil is amazing, very long-lasting and convenient. It just ran out after 3 uses... or maybe I'm missing something)))

The Olive colored pencil is simply amazing! It has a very pleasant texture and is easy to apply. And the color is just fantastic - I have been looking for one like this for a long time! Plus, it has a beautiful satin effect!

I really liked these pencils. They come in gel blue, beige, and purple. They hold up well and the color is vibrant. I use them to line my lash line and waterline. However, they are difficult to remove and require oil-based or dual-phase makeup removers. I never thought of using them for eyeliner because it would be hard to remove. But without that, the pencils wouldn't be long-lasting. It's either this or that.

Terrible pencil! The first disappointment in my collection(((( It only draws clumps, I couldn't achieve a smooth line. On my small eyelids, it looks like something smeared, as if I slept with painted eyes, woke up, and went out unwashed. It's frustrating(

The product I received is not at all like the one in the photo. I have always used this olive-colored one, and it was completely the same color as the pen body. But now, the one I received is completely white, with only the tip in olive color. Even the shade of the pen tip is different, and the pen itself is inconsistent with some holes throughout.

Excellent :)

I didn't buy it here, but I will write a review.

I got shade 50 - matte beige for applying under the eye. There is quite a lot left between the lashes, so I try to do it more carefully. You can get used to it.

The effect is eye enlargement, it looks amazing!
Perfect for my sensitive eyes with contact lenses.