Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara

What do you see in front of you right now? It's a treasure! I actually bought a waterproof one by accident and was a bit shocked that nothing could wash it off, but then I learned about two-phase products. So, Nivea's two-phase micellar water removes it in just seconds without any rubbing or suffering. This mascara is the only one that holds the curl after curling the lashes, it applies easily, makes the lashes extremely long, and doesn't flake off. The best mascara ever!

Honest review of this mascara

I am shocked by this purchase. The mascara arrived without any protective packaging, except for an unclear sticker, and the jar was half empty. It gives the impression that it has already been used. I do not recommend this website or the mascara.

The mascara is of excellent quality and does not clump like other mascaras from this brand.

I don't know why my review disappeared, so I'm duplicating it.

This mascara is not waterproof. It washed off from the tips after 3 times of washing my face with warm water, even though I bought it specifically for swimming in the pool. As a result, I had panda eyes and black particles underneath my eyes, and there were also residues on my lashes. It washed off easily with regular makeup remover.

The mascara applies nicely, it doesn't clump or flake.

It might be suitable for protecting against rain, snow, and tears, but not for swimming. Maybe someone can recommend a truly waterproof mascara?

The mascara arrived half-empty! It feels like I wasted 300 UAH! ((

I have been buying this mascara multiple times and I really like it. The only drawback is that it dries out after 4 months. However, the quality is superb and I have no issues swimming in the pool while wearing it.

I didn't buy it here, but I am satisfied with the product. It doesn't spill or clump. It doesn't smudge on the eyelids. It easily and effortlessly removes with a two-phase makeup remover, even without streaks.

I like mascaras that make my lashes voluminous and separate each hair, but this one is not really designed for that. However, I fell for the advertisement and bought it. It gives a wow effect in terms of length, so it would be suitable for those who like that, but I didn't like it. It slightly clumps the lashes, but if you comb them separately with a clean brush, it looks fine. However, it dries out the skin under the eyes and flakes off. I definitely won't buy it again. By the way, it works much better on fake lashes.

I don't understand the hype about this mascara. If you're looking for volume, this is not the right choice. It seems to focus more on separating the lashes. However, when you try to layer it, it clumps together and is difficult to remove.

I would rate it 0 out of 10. The mascara is simply terrible; it clings to the lashes like super glue and is impossible to remove. Neither micellar water, soap, nor gel can take it off. It comes off along with the lashes and also forms clumps. It's a complete waste of money, just awful.

Good mascara. I enjoy using it. It doesn't smudge, smear, or cause any irritation.

This is a nightmare, it clumps the lashes in one stroke, it dries instantly, you can't even fix it in time. And removing it is just a quest, the hydrophilic oil can't handle it. It simply forms clumps... Not worth your money... The only plus - it is definitely waterproof.

Overall, this mascara is not bad at all. It really does lengthen the lashes, but it did not pass the test of a short crying session - it smudged a bit and gave me the "panda" look. It probably wouldn't be suitable for the beach, so I will also test it in rainy weather.

The best mascara in my life! I have been using it for about 2 years. Everyone complains that it is impossible to remove, but thanks to the hydrophilic oil, it easily washes off. It amazingly curls and lengthens the lashes, and the applicator is fantastic. I highly recommend it from the bottom of my heart!

The mascara is truly waterproof, lengthens lashes, and overall looks great on the eyes. However, removing it is a nightmare! I struggle to remove it with an oil-based micellar water. It has broken all of my lashes.

I received the mascara without any packaging. In other words, it could have been opened at any time and already dried out. Well, makeup, what the hell? I haven't ordered from you in a year because last time, after placing the order, it took me weeks to get my shipment without any notification. Alright, you fixed the delivery, but what about the packaging? I haven't tested the mascara yet, I will add more later.

I bought this mascara based on the great reviews, but the reality turned out to be different. The only positive thing about it is that it incredibly lengthens the lashes and is very long-lasting. However, the consistency of the mascara is terrible (it might be suitable for those who like spider legs), but I prefer when my lashes are separated. It is very difficult to apply it with the original brush, and it doesn't comb well with other brushes.

The mascara is excellent! I have been searching for a mascara for sensitive eyes, oily skin, and one that doesn't smudge or flake onto my contact lenses for years. I agree with the other girls that it is difficult to remove, but I switched from micellar water to a remover specifically designed for waterproof mascara, and the problem was solved. It applies easily and stays on all day without any issues. I have no complaints at all.

It does not crumble, easily washes off with foamy washbasins, but since it is new, small clumps may stick together. It does a great job in extending lashes.

Great mascara. I remove it with a two-phase makeup remover from L'Oréal. It doesn't smudge or leave marks.

I really liked it. This mascara is super long-lasting, with a great brush, and now it will definitely be my favorite.

The mascara is truly waterproof, and Garnier micellar water does not remove it easily. The application is strange, and I was expecting much better results.

This mascara is great! Out of all the five mascaras I've tried, this one is the best.

The package arrived without being sealed. The product itself looks strange and still leaves marks under the eyes, as if I were a raccoon. Overall, a complete disappointment.

This product is excellent, and I highly recommend it.

This mascara is great! The brush is convenient and it coats the lashes nicely. Usually, waterproof mascaras are very liquidy in the beginning, for the first couple of weeks, but this one has a good consistency right away. It comes off very easily with a two-phase makeup remover.

The only good thing about it is its lasting power. However, the brush is terrible as it clumps the lashes and they stick out in different directions with chunks. I have to resort to using the brush from my old mascara.

Great mascara, it doesn't smudge, doesn't flake, and is not afraid of rain/snow/pool. It easily washes off with a dual-phase makeup remover (just like any other waterproof mascara). While it is still very fresh, I always wipe the brush on a tissue before applying it to my lashes. This helps to avoid the spider leg effect.

This is a great waterproof mascara that is perfect for both winter and extremely hot summers. The only downside is that it seemed a bit dry and there was no packaging.

I didn't like it: the brush is too long and flexible, there is no volume on the lashes at all. I won't buy it again.

The mascara in the tube feels a bit insufficient, and the volumizing function for the lashes is practically non-existent. However, it does perform well in terms of waterproofing. When applying, it is necessary to have a second spare brush for separating the lashes. It takes a little longer to remove with a two-phase makeup remover compared to regular mascara. Nonetheless, having a waterproof mascara in your makeup bag is always handy, especially during the summer or even in winter, as regular mascara from Maybelline tends to leave marks on the eyebrows when it rains or in high humidity conditions.

The fact that it is 100% waterproof is a great advantage, as it doesn't smudge even in extreme heat or during rain. However, I find the brush to be not very convenient, as it is too flexible and doesn't hold enough mascara. It dries quickly, so sometimes applying a second layer doesn't look nice, and with just one layer, the lashes appear very thin. Overall, it fulfills its main function of being waterproof, but I am not satisfied with the application and volume it provides.

While it has 4 stars, this product is truly waterproof. It is very difficult to wash off! On the lashes, it appears to be a 4 out of 5. It dries quickly on the lashes. Vivienne Sabo was my previous choice, but I decided to try something new because Vivienne dries quickly in the tube on its own. Let's see how long this one lasts.

The mascara is really cool; it lengthens the lashes and is waterproof.

This mascara is absolutely amazing.

I really liked this mascara! It doesn't clump or smudge, the brush is great, and it coats and separates my lashes beautifully. Many people thought I had extensions, but when they found out it was just mascara without any lengthening effect, they couldn't believe it and asked which mascara I use for coloring.

Waterproof and doesn't smudge, that's all I can say positively about it. Vivienne Sabo's mascara is better and cheaper. I was very disappointed from the first glance. The packaging is the cheapest plastic. There is no packaging or protection, so you can't even be sure that nobody used it before you. The dispenser popped out after about 2 weeks. There's a lot of advertising, but in reality, it's just okay. I won't be buying it again.

No complaints about the makeup itself. They are always excellent.

This product is truly waterproof and does not smudge or run. However, it is important to note that it dries very quickly, so there won't be an opportunity to make any touch-ups (unless you separate the lashes) or apply a second coat, as it will result in clumps. But if you have experience, there should be no issues.
The cone-shaped silicone brush is very convenient and allows for precise application even in the corners.
There is a similar non-waterproof version available, which is easier to work with.

I have been buying this mascara for the second time. One of its advantages is that it is indeed long-lasting. However, that's about it. I like it, but I only purchased it for its longevity. A significant downside is the application, as it is quite difficult to apply several layers without making it look clumpy, as it dries very quickly. You have to distribute the product very precisely from the start, as there is no way to fix any mistakes. For me, it is perfect for a "natural makeup" look with just one layer, and it stays on all day, even after tears or swimming. Therefore, I am satisfied with this purchase. I remove it with a regular waterproof makeup remover, and my lashes are in good condition.

Great mascara! It lengthens the lashes nicely and doesn't make them stick together. I remove it easily with regular makeup remover, even the "panda eyes" effect.

The product arrived without packaging, so it's unclear whether it has been used or opened before. This raises concerns about it drying out quickly, which is a downside for the makeup. I order this product very often, but such issues have a negative impact.

Good mascara, waterproof, can be removed with special products. The lashes don't stick together, the brush is amazing, thin, and very convenient. Out of all the waterproof mascaras I've tried, including the new Loreal one, this one surpasses them all. It's super-duper. No smudging or panda eyes when washing off with water.

I really liked this mascara. It applies smoothly and the brush is easy to use. The mascara is truly waterproof, it doesn't clump or smudge. I will definitely be ordering more.

I'm sorry, but this is a complete disappointment. The mascara is absolutely terrible, the worst from Maybelline of all time. It does nothing, doesn't curl, doesn't add volume, and clumps poorly. The only positive thing is that it's definitely waterproof, removing it is quite a challenge. I do NOT recommend wasting your money on it!

Great mascara, the silicone brush is very convenient and doesn't smudge on the eyelid. Of course, it needs to be removed with a two-phase makeup remover for waterproof cosmetics.

Ladies, if too much product accumulates on the brush from the tube, wipe the brush well on a dry tissue, then there will be no clumps, only beautifully coated lashes. This is the best approach with any new mascara if you don't want your lashes to stick together due to excess product.

It really stays on well, but it only applies smoothly with a maximum of 2-3 coats. Otherwise, everything clumps up and turns into spider-like folders. I applied it on top of another mascara to prevent the lash tips from smudging onto the eyelid.

This mascara is great, it doesn't smudge at all. It stays on well, but personally it didn't work for me as it clumped everything together. I tried to separate it, but too much product ended up on the brush. I don't regret trying it, but it dried up very quickly in the packaging, so I won't be buying it again next time.

I didn't buy it here. I have no complaints about the website, but the mascara is terrible. I fell for the advertisement. Don't buy it if you don't want to be left without eyelashes. It looks cheap. It incredibly clumps the lashes together. The waterproof aspect is good, but then it's impossible to remove even with a special remover, leaving a lot of my own lashes on the cotton pad after using it. The brush is too flexible, so while you're applying the mascara, everything around your eyes gets dirty. It lengthens like a regular mascara. The lashes look bad, clumped together, and there is no curl at all. The lashes become straight and clumped, and it's impossible to remove it afterwards. I don't understand why everyone recommends it.

I really like this mascara. I bought it based on reviews from this website. The waterproof effect was tested with heavy snow and tears. I even received a compliment, "Are those your natural lashes?" It's a shame that someone didn't appreciate this mascara or there was something wrong with it. There are drops of water from the mascara on the lashes, but it doesn't bother my lashes because now I have this mascara! )))) However, a regular micellar water couldn't handle it. And right away, on the website, I read in the reviews about buying the L'Oreal two-phase waterproof makeup remover. Now everything is super! I'm satisfied.