Reviews about Eveline Cosmetics Eyeliner Pencil

I bought the brown and black ones a couple of months ago. Honestly, I didn't like either of them. They don't last long, the colors are not vibrant, and there is very little difference between the brown and black shades for some reason. It's difficult to apply them smoothly, and they leave marks. The eyeliners are terrible. I don't use them for my eyes anymore, but the black one works decently for my black eyebrows as it can be blended well with a brush. The packaging for sharpening is also inconvenient; it's easier to sharpen them separately. In short, it's possible to use them, but it's challenging.

I have purchased this product before. It is a fantastic budget pencil.

I have been using Evelyn brand pencils ever since they appeared on the Ukrainian cosmetics market, which is already more than 20 years ago.

I am satisfied with this product. It does not leak and has good quality.

As for its price, this product is good; it enhances the eyes and feels comfortable. I will definitely purchase it again.

I really liked this pencil, it is easy to apply and long-lasting. Moreover, it is also of a great size!

I really liked the pencil, it applies easily and blends smoothly.

For such a price, you shouldn't expect anything extraordinary. It smudges a lot, making you look like a panda in the evening.

Good pencil, but it smudges easily.

For its price, this pencil is excellent.

This is a good quality pencil. It draws easily and lasted a whole day without any changes. The color is a dark brown. I use it for eyeliner. I haven't applied it on my inner rim.

Great pencil,

The incredible pencil applies easily and lasts long. It does not smudge even under the rain.

This is a good pencil with a rich black color, although it doesn't really last long. When I apply it to my lower eyelid, I either use Kail from L'Amel or I apply eyeshadow on top of it, then it stays for about 5 hours.

I really like this pencil; it's not the first time I've bought it.

Easy to apply! However, over time, it tends to smudge, which is its downside.

This pencil is very good.

Not bad, the pencil is quite soft, you can draw arrows with it, the only question is about its durability, or rather its absence.

I didn't have a good experience with it, the arrow doesn't come out smooth(((

This is a great budget eyeliner pencil, it keeps my eyeliner intact for several hours :)

Pencil for 3, it will do for this price. I bought it to line my eyes, but it's not long-lasting at all. After an hour, you end up looking like a panda.

The pencil is decent, soft. One downside is its longevity. It needs to be applied moderately so that later on, the excess can be maintained after some time.

Pros: Easy to blend, soft, affordable.
Cons: Poor staying power, not long-lasting.

I have been using Eveline pencils for many years, specifically this series. I buy the black one for my eyes and the brown one for my eyebrows. It stays on my eyes for at least 12 hours, and even longer on my eyebrows.

The pencil is excellent! It stays on perfectly, even on the mucous membrane. It doesn't smudge and applies easily. The price is fantastic.

The pencil is great. It meets many of my criteria for such a price: it applies beautifully, lasts well, is easily washed off, is long enough, has a sharpener, lasts a long time, and is also affordable.

The pencil is quite good, but it also has its drawbacks. Pros: soft, erases easily, applies smoothly, affordable. Cons: not long-lasting. The sharpener is convenient, but sometimes the pencil sharpens itself when it's not needed. The pencil itself is soft, but it doesn't stay on the eyes well.

This pencil is amazing. I have allergies, and it's difficult for me to find an eyeliner pencil (Maybelline caused a terrible allergy). Only Avon pencils suit me, so I recently ordered this one because the price was acceptable. And what a miracle! It's black, glides smoothly, doesn't scratch, blends well, and stays on the waterline fairly well (you can occasionally touch up your makeup). I am satisfied.

Easy to apply and stays in place! First class for the price!

This is a good quality black pencil.

After a hundred attempts to switch to another product, I always end up coming back to this pencil. However, I use it for my eyes, not my eyebrows. The brown color reveals a much deeper shade in the eyeliner than the black one.

Not bad for its price, it lasts me a long time. I bought it to accentuate my lash line and it does a great job. It is also convenient for drawing winged eyeliner. The sharpener gets clogged sometimes, but that's natural. There is a small detachable tool at the bottom to clean the sharpener. Overall, it's a decent black pencil, I recommend it as a budget option.

The color of the pencil is wonderful. It's a deep brown, almost black. I have dark hair, but black is too intense for me, I wanted something more natural. However, the pencil is not soft enough, I have to apply it with some effort. It's not a big issue, but still...

This is a good pencil, soft and it didn't cause any allergies. However, it's not long-lasting and tends to smudge a bit, requiring frequent touch-ups, especially during the summer.

The pencil is average, just like the price, which should be taken into account. It draws the waterline well, but it's difficult to make a good line on the eyelids with it, and creating a nice winged eyeliner is not easy either.

Great pencil. I bought it in black. I don't apply it to the inner part of my eyelid. I only use it for eyeliner. It stays on the base all day long, even in hot weather, until I remove it. The only downside is the smell.

Convenient, spacious, and a great color choice... but not at all long-lasting. I bought it for light at-home makeup, and after a few hours, it's almost gone.

Pros:
Comparatively low price, sufficiently long, comes with a sharpener that works until the end. Moderately soft, applying it is a pleasure. The color is a rich black, but it's soft, slightly muted, not like eyeliners, but gentle. It draws smoothly without smudging, if I can put it that way. Perfect for everyday use, subtle and stylish. I only line the outer corners of my eyes.

Cons:
It does leave a slight imprint on the upper eyelid, not too noticeable though. It's a perpetual problem for me. I found a solution: I lightly apply lighter eyeshadows on the eyelid and use a thin brush to apply powder on the outer corners of my eyes (only compact powder, otherwise the loose powder falls onto the lashes). Then I draw a winged line on top. The eye makeup turns out to be in a Nude style. And miraculously, it stays put!

Here's a photo after a workday, in the heat, wearing a mask, and taking a bus ride. The pencil stays on even when the entire face is "melting" and shining. I highly recommend it! I don't want to change it! I have purchased it multiple times already!

Both the black and brown colors are fabulous.

The mattress is too firm for my liking. I would prefer something softer. After an hour of lying on it, I felt like a panda. I do not recommend it.